She & Him Setlist — Town Hall, New York (2026-09-23)

She & Him live at Town Hall in New York, United States on 2026-09-23.

She & Him setlist — Town Hall, New York (2026-09-23)

28 songs, in the order played:

  1. I've Got Your Number, Son
  2. I Was Made for You
  3. In the Sun
  4. Over It Over Again
  5. Ridin' in My Car
  6. Don't Look Back
  7. Take It Back
  8. This Is Not a Test
  9. You've Really Got a Hold on Me
  10. Stars Fell on Alabama
  11. Darlin'
  12. Lingering Still
  13. Baby
  14. Thieves
  15. Sentimental Heart
  16. Gonna Get Along Without You Now
  17. Magic Trick
  18. Turn to White
  19. I Thought I Saw Your Face Today
  20. Change Is Hard
  21. Fools Rush In (Where Angels Fear to Tread)
  22. Black Hole
  23. Never Wanted Your Love
  24. I Could've Been Your Girl
  25. Why Do You Let Me Stay Here?
  26. Roll Over Beethoven
  27. Sweet Darlin'
  28. I Put a Spell on You

Source: setlist.fm

Setlist data powered by setlist.fm.

About this show

This page tracks the She & Him concert at Town Hall, New York on 2026-09-23. Open the live page to see who attended from the Gigvault community, photos and concert notes — and mark it as attended in one tap.

Frequently asked questions

What did She & Him play at Town Hall, New York on 2026-09-23?

She & Him played 28 songs that night, listed above in the order they were performed, opening with "I've Got Your Number, Son".

How many songs did She & Him play at this concert?

28, closing with "I Put a Spell on You".

What did She & Him open with at Town Hall, New York?

"I've Got Your Number, Son" — the first song of the night on 2026-09-23. The full running order is listed above.

What song did She & Him close with?

"I Put a Spell on You" was the last song played at Town Hall, New York. Gigvault does not record which songs were part of an encore, so this is the final song of the set as it was logged.

Was I at this She & Him concert?

Mark it as attended on Gigvault and it becomes part of your concert history — with the setlist, your photos and the friends who were there. Free, no credit card.

Track this concert

  1. Create a free Gigvault account.
  2. Mark this She & Him show as attended.
  3. Save the setlist, upload photos, tag friends.
  4. Your concert history feeds into stats, map and Wrapped automatically.

More She & Him concerts →   More shows at Town Hall →   More concerts in New York →

More She & Him concerts